Selle San Marco Trekking Saddle - Steel, Black, Men's, Large

Pros

It's on sale. It is black, so it matches just about any color. It is narrow enough that you're not having your legs splayed outward by a too wide seat, this I have learned means increased comfort. It has a little bit of cushioning so, yeah, you don't have to be so hard on your butt. I have turned my bike upside down on the asphalt to repair my bike on the road--showed scuff marks, but those scuff marks were "buffed out" by riding. After about 750 miles that seat still looks great!

Cons

If you're a weight weenie, this has steel (durable!) rails, so it weighs more than a carbon seat. It is black, so it heats up in the sun and could put you in the hot seat? I don't have any other real cons and that last one is dubious!

Other Thoughts

I had ignored the advice that excessive cushioning and a large size seat wouldn't necessarily provide more comfort. Lo and behold, the only seat of my 4 cruiser / trekking / cargo steel bicycles that was most comfortable was one very similar to the Selle San Marco Trekking Saddle. So, when it came time to replace one of the "overstuffed" seats, I chose the Selle San Marco. I have since bought a second one to replace another overstuffed, too large seat. I ride with Cane Creek suspension seat posts and with 2+ inches wide of tire to cushion, so your comfort mileage may vary.