Reviews of Brooks B67 Saddle Black

This is my second B67S. Still using my first one on my old bike. I like it well enough that I bought one for my second bike. It’s comfortable and gets more comfortable over time.

Pros

First, The service provided by Modern Bike was excellent. My order arrived very quickly. I haven’t ridden my bike very often since I purchased the saddle due to weather, limited daylight after work, demands at workplace, etc. The ride is SO much smoother than provided by any other non-spring seat that I’ve owned. It made me wonder why some version of a spring seat isn’t the norm on mountain bikes (I guess it’s because of the leaned forward, attack position on those bikes). I usually require a wide seat (140-150mm) and the shape and width are very good for me. I weigh about 250lbs and find the spring tension to be perfect to prevent most ‘bottoming” over average road, bike path and sidewalk deformities. The exceptional quality of the seat is obvious in every aspect. I expect, and look forward, to many years of service from this seat.

Cons

The saddle leather is quite firm but should take the needed shape as I ride more. The photos showed a textured surface and I didn’t realize the seat would be as slippery as it is. I constantly slide forward and need to slightly lower the back of the seat. I haven’t had any issues with the dye coming off of the seat and onto my shorts/pants.

Other Thoughts

I would love to try a version of this seat with the textured cover of the B17 Cambium to prevent sliding. I purchased an extra 25g tin of Brooks Proofide leather dressing. I will treat the leather often to help get the seat broken in ASAP. Treating the underside of the seat is inconvenient but this purchase is an investment and it won’t be as necessary after break-in.

Pros

Comfort
Durability

Cons

Cost.
Lack of weather resistance in a leather saddle

Other Thoughts

This is my second B-67 - rode the first one for 7 years and 35,000 miles before it died. Searched for 2 years trying different saddles before I found the Brooks B-67. It was the first one that was comfortable for my upright riding style and when it finally broke I bought another. Nuff said

Pros

Great saddle that will last forever. I have it on a 3 speed city bike. I ride 2000 miles per year and have over a dozen bikes, most of which are equipped with Brooks seats.

Cons

None really, but keep in mind that by nature a leather saddle requires a break in period to be comfortable.

Other Thoughts

A bicycle seat is only comfortable for long rides if the riders butt is also broke in. There is no substitute for hours in the saddle. NO seat is comfortable unless the rider does his/her part by putting in the miles.

Pros

Looks appropriately perfect on my Raleigh Twenty 3 speed. The springs help to even out the small wheel ride. Will last forever with care and feeding. Great for the upright sitting position. Sturdy and incredibly well built. Good deal and fairly fast shipping from Modern.

I have an older Brooks on another bicycle, the B66s double rail version, and it fits my sit bones beautifully now that it's broken in. So I knew this will become even better saddle down the road. The new B67s is lighter than the old version too.

Cons

Needs time riding to break it in... (the box includes a small packet of Brooks Proofhide so that's a good start).

Pros

comfortable, durable

Cons

none

Other Thoughts

A friend of mine has had his brooks saddle for about 20 years and its still going strong,

Pros

(-) Comfort! (-) Cool index (-) Worth every penny

Cons

(-) Price but is worth the money

Other Thoughts

I have ridden a Brooks B17 for years. It took about 700 miles to really break in for me. This B67 was perfect the moment I put it on my new fat bike. If you have the money I HIGHLY recommend this saddle.

Pros

This is simply the most elegant, highest quality, comfortable seat for women riding a "real" everyday, upright touring set up. It compliments my wife's 1975 Motobecane Grand Touring (her high school graduation present!) with NittoTechnomic stem/cromo Albatross upright bars perfectly. No backside numbness, or any discomfort whatsoever, gets better with use. Comfort trumps weight everyday in a touring configuration. She rides most days 15-20 miles. She has had Brooks on all her bikes, nothing else, for decades.

Cons

Carry a small plastic shopping bag always in case you get caught in rain...easy the seat has saddlebag loops.

Pros

Brooks standard of excellence is top notch. Great saddles (both mine and my wife's bikes now have Brooks saddlery.

Cons

To keep the leather supple and in good shape, they should be treated with a leather treatment every so often and before and after the seat gets wet.

Other Thoughts

Love these seats. Comfortable and very stylish!

This is all leather, on a wire frame which is kept at optimal tension by a adjuster bolt under the seat. This saddle needs 3 months breaking in, using the tin of oil which I purchased with the saddle. This is supposed to be the best comfortable long distance saddle on the market and if true is worth every penny !!! From every review I have found, everyone loves this saddle. Coupled with the NCX Suntour seatpost , my bike rides like a Cadillac !!! This saddle should last a lifetime....

Pros

Breaks in to your butt, which makes ride very comfortable. Will last lifetime with care. Can transfer from bike to bike. Never have to buy another saddle.

Cons

Pricey, but worth every cent..Keep it dry, do not let it stay in the rain. You can carry plastic bag and cover if needed. You must rub the leather oil into the saddle every so often.

Other Thoughts

I have a quick release seat post clamp, which enables me to keep my new saddle in the house and out of weather and thieving eyes....It is so much more comfortable already, compared to the factory foam saddle...

No break in time needed. Very comfortable and it looks awesome!

No break in time needed. Very comfortable and it looks awesome!

Pros

Excellent saddle for older riders, good price, fast shipping.

Cons

None

Pros

Simply the most comfortable and durable middle-distance commuter saddle available.

Unlike modern performance saddles, it conforms to you after break-in. You don't have to buy 5 saddles to find one that fits perfectly.

Cons

Break it in properly before you judge it, and keep it dry when you're not sitting on it. It wouldn't hurt to run your cable lock through it: it collects a lot of jealous glances. Though costly, it's in line with exotic composite designs.

Pros

General quality of craftsmanship
Comfort!

Cons

Fairly expensive

Other Thoughts

I have tried various wider and more padded saddles, staying away from the narrow saddles for years. The springs and slight increase in width help, and the narrower profile (compared to heavily padded seats) shelters me from upper leg discomfort that was limiting my comfortable time in the saddle. The difference between 50 and 100 mile days is in time now, not in comfort.

Pros

Looks fantastic, turns heads, instantly makes your bicycle look like a classic. After time, saddles of this type are far more comfortable than regular bicycle seats.

Cons

It will take some time to break it in. Do not expect to receive the comforting benefits of this type of saddle until after you have used it for about 200 miles. The leather is not waterproof. You need to keep it out of rain and avoid splashing water on it as much as possible. You should also consider buying a waterproof rain cover for this saddle.

Other Thoughts

You should soak this saddle with your favorite type of leather oil before you start using it. I used plain old baby oil and it works just fine. Drench the top and underside very well, let it soak in for about 30 minutes and then wipe off the excess. Then ride as much as possible.

Pros

Compared to typical road/race seat, the B67 saddle feels like there is more support surface, providing more positioning options for lengthy rides.

Cons

Leather seems to be as firm/hard, similar to the other Brooks seats. I had anticipated that the B67 would be more pliable based on reports from others who purchased the same bike seat.

Other Thoughts

I use the seat on a road bike - riding position is mostly leaning into an aerobar, but the bar is raised higher than what's usual. Had the first ride today and the experience left me feeling very optimistic about what to expect after an adjusting period. Happy with my choice.

Pros

after a short break in and some adjusting (including a Velo Orange seatpost to increase the setback), I love it!

Cons

it's a bit heavy but, it's on my touring bike so it's not a big deal

Pros

very comfortable, lasts forever, breaks in for 'custom' fit to your bottom, ideal for upright riding position, springs function as suspension

Cons

black dye bleeds out after oiling, either don't wear light colored pants or get the honey color saddle. not suitable for drop handlebars lower than saddle

Other Thoughts

sitting on this saddle is like putting on your favorite shoes. perfect fit

Pros

Brooks Saddles always please me for quality, craftsmanship and eventual comfort!

Cons

My 1979 IDEALE was actually made better than my Brooks, but are not still in business that I know of.

Pros

Brooks Saddles always please me for quality, craftsmanship and eventual comfort!

Cons

My 1979 IDEALE was actually made better than my Brooks, but are not still in business that I know of.